DexlinkerHonest notes on earning links

Judgement

How to evaluate a link before you chase it

Relevance, real traffic, editorial standards and spam signals. A practical scoring method for deciding whether a link opportunity is worth your time.

Link building takes time, and time spent on the wrong prospects is wasted. A link from a site that is irrelevant, has no real audience or sells links to anyone who asks will do little for you and may add risk. Before you write an outreach email, it is worth spending a couple of minutes deciding whether the link is worth having.

This guide gives a practical evaluation framework you can apply to any prospect, whether it comes from broken link building, digital PR, resource pages or an inbound offer.

The question behind every check

All the criteria below answer one underlying question: would this link exist, and be useful, if search engines did not count links? A link from a respected industry publication sends real readers and signals real endorsement. A link from a site built only to host links does neither. Search engines have spent two decades learning to tell the difference, and they are good at it.

1. Topical relevance

Relevance is the most important factor, and the one that third-party metrics do not measure. Ask:

  • Does the site cover topics related to yours, or that your customers care about?
  • Is the specific page relevant, not just the site as a whole?
  • Would a reader of that page plausibly want to visit yours?

A link from a well-read accounting blog to an invoicing tool is relevant. A link from the same blog to a pet supplies store is not, however strong the blog is. Links that make no topical sense are a common feature of paid placements, and search engines are well aware of that pattern.

2. Real organic traffic

A site that receives real search traffic is one that search engines trust enough to rank. A site with strong-looking link metrics but almost no organic traffic is a warning sign: it may have been penalised, built only to sell links or simply abandoned.

SEO tools estimate organic traffic and show its trend over time. Look for:

  • A reasonable amount of traffic for the niche. Small niche sites will have modest numbers, and that is fine.
  • A stable or growing trend. A sharp, sustained drop often indicates an algorithmic problem.
  • Traffic coming from keywords related to the site's topic, not from unrelated terms.

3. Editorial quality

Spend two minutes reading the site. Real publications have recognisable signs:

  • Named authors with a track record, an about page and a clear owner.
  • Original content with a consistent topic focus.
  • Articles that link out to sources because they are useful, not to random commercial sites.
  • Reader engagement: comments, social shares, newsletter subscribers.

Warning signs include articles on wildly unrelated topics side by side, generic content with no clear author, and obvious "write for us" pages advertising do-follow links for a price.

Look at where the site already links. Open a few recent articles and check the outbound links:

  • Do they go to relevant, reputable sources?
  • Does almost every article contain a commercial link with keyword-rich anchor text to an unrelated business?
  • Are there categories such as "sponsored", "partner content" or "guest post" with dozens of entries from different businesses?

A site that links out to casino, loan, supplement and software sites in the same week is selling links. Search engines have algorithms specifically designed to recognise and devalue links from such sites, which means your link would likely carry no value even if it carried no penalty.

Where the link sits on the page matters:

PlacementTypical valueNotes
In the body of a relevant articleHighestEditorial context, read by real visitors
In a curated resource listGoodValuable when the list is maintained and selective
In an author bioModestFine for genuine contributions, weak on its own
Sidebar or footer, site-wideLow and riskyCommon pattern in paid links
User-generated comments or profilesVery lowUsually marked ugc or nofollow

Check the link attribute too. Links marked rel="nofollow", rel="sponsored" or rel="ugc" are hints to search engines and may not pass ranking signals. They can still send traffic, but they should not be counted as ranking links in your planning.

6. Third-party authority metrics

Domain Authority, Domain Rating and similar scores are useful shorthand, but they are estimates built from each tool's own crawl, not Google data. They have known weaknesses: they can be inflated by spammy links, they do not account for relevance and they say nothing about whether a site sells links. If you want a deeper explanation of what these scores measure and where they mislead, see this primer on domain authority.

Use metrics to compare similar prospects or to filter out the weakest ones, never as the main reason to pursue a link. A high score combined with low traffic and no relevance is a common signature of a site built for selling links.

7. Spam signals checklist

If a prospect shows several of these signs, move on:

  • A "write for us" page that mentions do-follow links, pricing or turnaround times.
  • Many unrelated topics with no editorial focus.
  • Authority score high, organic traffic close to zero.
  • Traffic that dropped sharply and never recovered.
  • The domain recently changed ownership and topic, for example an old charity site now publishing gambling reviews.
  • Thin, generic articles that read like they were produced in bulk.
  • Outbound links in almost every post to commercial sites in unrelated industries.
  • The site appears in marketplaces or lists of sites selling guest posts.

The changed-ownership pattern deserves special mention. Google's spam policies include "expired domain abuse": buying an expired domain with existing links and repurposing it to host low-value content. Links from such domains are a liability rather than an asset.

A simple scoring method

To make decisions consistent across a team, score each prospect from 0 to 2 on five criteria:

Criterion012
RelevanceUnrelatedAdjacent topicSame topic or audience
Organic trafficNone or collapsedLow but stableHealthy for the niche
Editorial qualityGeneric or spammyAcceptableRecognised, expert content
Outbound link patternSells linksUnclearLinks only to useful sources
Likely placementFooter, bio or commentsResource listContextual, in body

A total of 8 to 10 is a priority prospect. A score of 5 to 7 is worth pursuing if the effort is low. Below 5, skip it. Any 0 on relevance or outbound link pattern should normally disqualify a prospect, whatever the total.

If you run a site of any size, you will receive emails offering links, guest posts or "collaboration". Apply the same criteria, and add one more: is money or an exchange involved? If so, the link is a paid link under search engine guidelines and should either be declined or marked as sponsored. Our article on why to avoid PBNs and paid link packages explains why these offers are rarely worth it.

Takeaway. A good link is relevant, comes from a site with a real audience and was placed because it helps readers. Metrics help you filter; judgement makes the decision.

Frequently asked questions

Is Domain Authority a Google metric?

No. Domain Authority (Moz), Domain Rating (Ahrefs) and Authority Score (Semrush) are third-party estimates based on each tool's own link index. Google has said it does not use them. They are useful for rough comparison, but they can be inflated and should never be the only criterion.

Should I avoid links from low-authority sites?

Not necessarily. A small, highly relevant site with a real audience, such as a niche blog written by a practitioner, can be a better link than a large, generic site. Relevance and genuineness matter more than scores.

What should I do about spammy links I did not build?

Most sites receive some random spammy links and Google says it generally ignores them. The disavow tool is intended mainly for cases where you have a manual action or know of a significant number of unnatural links that you or someone on your behalf built.