DexlinkerHonest notes on earning links

Tactic

Broken link building, step by step

Find dead links on relevant pages, offer a genuinely better replacement and make the webmaster's job easier. A complete workflow with templates.

Every website decays. Pages get deleted, companies shut down, URLs change during redesigns and nobody updates the links that pointed to them. Studies of link rot consistently find that a large share of links on the web eventually stop working; a 2024 Pew Research Center analysis found that around a quarter of web pages that existed at some point between 2013 and 2023 were no longer accessible.

Broken link building uses that decay. When you find a relevant page linking to a dead resource, you can offer the site owner a working replacement: your page. You fix a problem on their site and they gain a better user experience. Done properly, it is one of the most honest and repeatable link building methods available.

Why it works

Most link requests ask a stranger to do you a favour. Broken link outreach is different because you start with something useful to them: a specific problem on their page. Webmasters care about broken links because they frustrate readers and make content look neglected. Pointing one out is a small service, and offering a replacement makes fixing it effortless.

The tactic fails when the replacement is weak or only loosely related. If the dead link pointed to a detailed guide on email deliverability and you offer your product's pricing page, the request makes no sense. The whole method depends on having content that genuinely fills the gap.

Step 1: Start with your own site

Before hunting for broken links elsewhere, fix the ones on your own site. Broken internal links waste crawl budget and lose visitors, and old URLs on your site that now return 404 may still have external links pointing at them. Redirecting those URLs to the most relevant current page reclaims value with no outreach at all.

A site crawler or a technical SEO audit will list broken internal links and pages returning errors. Google Search Console's page indexing report also shows URLs that return "Not found (404)". Check which of them have backlinks, and redirect those first.

There are three common routes to prospects. Each produces different kinds of opportunities.

RouteHow it worksStrength
Resource pagesSearch for curated link lists in your niche and check them for dead linksMany relevant links per page, high relevance
Dead competitor or industry pagesUse a backlink tool to find pages in your niche that return 404 but still have many referring domainsOne dead page can mean dozens of prospects
Defunct sites and toolsLook for businesses, tools or projects in your field that shut downOften many links to replace at once

For resource pages, useful search queries include your topic + "useful links", your topic + "resources" and intitle:links your topic. Run each page through a broken link checker browser extension or a crawler to find dead outbound links quickly.

For dead pages, most backlink tools let you filter a competitor's or a niche site's pages by HTTP status. Sort the 404 pages by the number of referring domains. A dead page that once had a few dozen relevant sites linking to it is a strong prospect, because every one of those sites now has a broken link.

Step 3: Understand what the dead page was

Before deciding whether you can replace a dead resource, find out exactly what it contained. The Internet Archive's Wayback Machine usually has copies of pages that once received links. Look at:

  • The topic and depth of the content.
  • Its format: guide, tool, statistic, template or directory.
  • Why people linked to it. Read a few of the linking pages and note the context of each link.

The last point matters most. If most people linked to the dead page to cite a single statistic, your replacement needs that kind of statistic, up to date and properly sourced. If they linked to a tool, a text article will not replace it.

Step 4: Create or improve the replacement

If you already have a page that does the job, update it so it covers what the dead page covered. If not, decide whether creating one is worth it. A useful rule: only create the page if it fits your site's topic and you would be happy to have it even without the links.

A good replacement should:

  • Cover what the original covered, with current information.
  • Be better in at least one clear way: more current, more complete, easier to use or with original data.
  • Not be a disguised sales page. Educational content gets linked; product pitches do not.
  • Be written in your own words. Use the archived page only to understand the gap.

Step 5: Qualify the prospects

Not every page with a broken link is worth contacting. Before outreach, check each prospect using the criteria from our guide on how to evaluate a link: is the site relevant, does it have real traffic, is it maintained, and does it show signs of selling links? Abandoned pages that nobody has edited for years are unlikely to be updated now.

Then find the right person to contact. On small sites that is the owner; on larger ones, the author of the article or the editor of that section. A personal address gets far better results than a generic contact form.

Step 6: Write the outreach email

Keep it short, specific and helpful. Mention the exact page and the exact broken link so the recipient can verify it in seconds.

Subject: Broken link on your "email deliverability resources" page

Hi Sam,

I was reading your list of email deliverability resources and noticed that the link to the "Sender Reputation Guide" in the third section now returns a 404. The site seems to have shut down.

If you are looking for a replacement, we published an updated guide covering the same topics, including the authentication requirements that changed recently: [URL]. Happy if it's useful, and either way, thought you'd want to know about the dead link.

Best,
Alex

Note what the email does not do: it does not demand a link, it does not flatter excessively, and it does not hide the fact that the replacement is yours. It reports a real problem and offers a real solution.

Step 7: Follow up once, then move on

If there is no reply after about a week, one short follow-up is reasonable. After that, stop. Repeated emails damage your reputation and the domain you send from.

Record every outcome in a simple tracker: prospect URL, broken link, contact, date sent, follow-up date and result. Over time it shows which kinds of prospects convert and which do not, and it prevents the embarrassment of emailing the same person twice about the same link.

Common mistakes

  • Weak replacements. If your page is thinner than the dead one, the request is not credible.
  • Templated emails at scale. Site owners recognise generic broken link pitches immediately.
  • Offering payment. Paying for the replacement link turns a white-hat tactic into a link scheme.
  • Ignoring relevance. A dead link on an unrelated site is not an opportunity, however strong the domain looks.
  • Not checking that the link is truly dead. Temporary outages and redirects happen. Confirm the status before writing.

Takeaway. Broken link building is a quality filter as much as a link tactic. If you cannot produce a page good enough to replace a resource that people once chose to link to, the outreach will not work, and that tells you something useful about your content.

Frequently asked questions

Is broken link building still effective?

Yes, when the replacement page is genuinely good and relevant. Response rates are lower than they were a decade ago because the tactic became popular and many site owners receive generic requests. Personalised emails that point to the exact broken link and offer a real replacement still work.

Should I recreate a dead page that had many links?

If the topic fits your site and you can produce something at least as useful, yes. Use the archived version to understand what it covered, but write your own content and update it. Copying the old page wholesale is both a copyright problem and a missed chance to improve on it.

How many outreach emails should I expect to send per link?

It varies widely by niche and quality of the prospect list. Many practitioners treat a response rate in the single-digit to low double-digit percentages as normal. Improving targeting usually raises results more than sending more emails.